Saturday, January 26, 2013

Reading Resposne 4

In chapter 5 of Karen Armstrong's book she starts to talk about the Israelites time in Babylon and how they wanted to make themselves separate from their Babylonian neighbors.  From her point of view it seems this is where customs like circumcision and food laws really become important for the Jewish faith.  Another important thing that appears to have come out of this time period is the idea of god or Yahweh being mobile.  This idea is one we still carry around today believing that we can pray from basically any physical place that we are.  Something that was hard for me to grasp was after saying Yahweh was moblie, Armstrong states he left the Israelites who stated in Jerusalem.  While this isn't really factual and is passed down oral tradition, I would assume, this is just the interpretation of those who were exiled to Babylon.  I sometimes find it hard to keep in mind this book is simply peoples interpretation of history, whether through written accounts or oral tradition or however she found her sources. I constantly find myself thinking how does she really know that is what happened or what the people thought.  Though there are some obviously important changes made during this period to the religion of Judaism, the exact stories she gives of how they happened are often hard to follow and believe.

1 comment:

  1. Hey Jennifer,

    The only stories that we have access too from the exile to Babylonia are the written stories. All those that didn't write, all those writings that were lost, we won't know exactly what people thought. So basically, we don't have an accurate sense of the diversity of theological opinions of Jews in exile in Babylonia, or for that matter of almost anytime, until much more recently, with such advances as the printing press, and now the Internet.

    Yeah it's strange how God suddenly became mobile. I thought that God had been mobile all of the time, because God had traveled with the Israelites through the Sinai, on their way out of Egypt. On top of that, God's mobility seems restricted to being in one place at one time. But what happens when the Jews in exile in Babylonia felt the presence of God, and the Jews that remained in Samaria also felt the presence... Uh oh, now we're getting deep. So even though God became mobile, God could only be in one place at a time...

    ReplyDelete